When Van Williams and Jeff Loomis unveiled the teaser for Nevermore’s new chapter earlier this week, the reaction from fans was a mix of excitement and criticism. Some celebrated the revival of a band that shaped the landscape of progressive metal, while others questioned the absence of Jim Sheppard – fueled by Jim‘s wife’s own words about the band’s revival – and the path forward without Warrel Dane. In an open letter published on social media today (December 31st), Van and Jeff have responded candidly, offering a window into the decisions and emotions driving this ambitious endeavor.
“So, the Nevermore teaser has sparked a lot of positivity and some expected negativity. Let me (Van) address the negative first. Some people think it’s disrespectful not to involve Jim or inform him of our plans. But those who feel that way don’t know the history of the band or the behind-the-scenes dynamics that led to this decision. While it may not have been the most ideal approach, the reality is that there hasn’t been communication with Jim in years,” Williams explained.
This frank acknowledgment of criticism sets the tone for what follows. Van doesn’t shy away from admitting the complexity of these decisions, emphasizing that they were made to move forward, not dwelling on the past.
“We felt that sometimes, for the sake of a fresh start, it’s necessary to move on from relationships that may no longer be conducive to growth or new beginnings. We made this decision with the intention of honoring the legacy of the band while moving forward in a way that felt right for us at the time. That said, we wish him good health and he is free to pursue whatever path he chooses. Without going into too much detail, I’ll just say respect goes both ways, and certain things became irreconcilable over time for us. At this point in my life, I don’t feel the need to explain myself further on this, so take from that what you will.”
For Van, Nevermore represents more than a musical project — it’s a lifelong passion that brought equal measures of joy and heartbreak. He recounts the band’s decline with brutal honesty, capturing the weight of its disintegration while reaffirming his pride in what they achieved.
“As for why I’m revisiting Nevermore, it’s simple, this band has always been my dream. To find a group of guys to be in a band with and travel the world and create music. After auditioning to the moment I was asked to join, it was a whirlwind of music, art, creativity, adventure, fun, and camaraderie. Over the years, we made incredible music and amazing memories together. But as time went on, things spiraled out of control… trust, respect, and the joy of it all started to disappear. I always compare it to an analogy like having a cake and eating it too, but in our case, it turned into having a cake covered in shit frosting… You wanna eat it but it’s covered in shit! The final breaking point came during the last leg of our European tour with Symphony X, after which it was clear we couldn’t continue as we were. After years of us building the best band we could for ourselves we couldn’t get on the same page to fix it. Jeff and I went one way; Warrel and Jim went another. There was no reconciliation. Warrel went to Brazil, Jim retired to Alaska, and years passed without contact.”
He also reflects on personal tragedy: “During this time, my personal life took a devastating turn when my wife was diagnosed with ovarian cancer. We did everything to create a sense of normalcy for our little boy and we did our best to make her comfortable. Warrel would occasionally call from Brazil, and while we exchanged kind words during those calls, it didn’t erase the past and I can tell that certain things haven’t changed. Dore passed on in 2020, and her loss crushed me and my boy, we feel that loss still to this day. I personally feel like I am just starting to come out of a coma truth be told and thank God I’m finally seeing the light and grateful for who and what I still have in my life. I’ll never be able to express the gratitude I feel for my family, close friends, and fans who helped me and my family through all the dark days. Thank you all so very much for helping me get through the toughest times.”
Through it all, his bond with Jeff remained unbroken. Their shared love for music ultimately rekindled their drive to revisit Nevermore: “Through it all, Jeff remained one of my strongest supporters, and our bond deepened. Over time, we both missed the joy of creating and performing together. Nevermore was a huge part of that joy, something I’m tremendously proud of.”
Jeff’s further contributions to the letter, underscore his shared commitment to the band’s legacy: “I couldn’t agree more with Van’s statement. There have obviously been a lot of ups and downs with Nevermore’s past history. I’d like to just remember the good ones while carrying the torch with Van to yet another level of the band. My heart has always been in it for the music, touring and performing. I’ve had some great times playing with other musicians these past 10-11 years, but Nevermore has been and will always be my personal portal to some of the best music I’ve ever done and created.”
“No one can replace Warrel Dane. Bottom line. With his interesting melodies and charisma onstage, he was a force that was a huge part of the band both lyrically and spiritually. With that being said, we aren’t looking for a Warrel Dane clone. We are looking for someone who can carry the older Nevermore tunes in his vocal style, and someone who can add something new and refreshing to the next chapter of the band. Obviously, this won’t be the easiest thing to do.”
“With all this being said, we are going on a WORLD SEARCH seeking two extraordinary musicians. One main lead vocalist, and one bass player to join the fold and help carry our legacy forward. We have since filled the position of a second guitarist, but more on that a bit later in another update!”
For those interested in auditioning for the vocalist position, the requirements are clear. “We want individuals who bring good energy to the band dynamic. We’re seeking people who can maintain focus, professionalism, and respect for the music. Someone who is reliable, prepared and has a strong work ethic. You must be open to extensive worldwide touring with an active and current passport. A willingness to work together creatively, support each other, and represent Nevermore with Integrity on and off the stage.”
Singers: Submit a video of yourself singing the songs ‘Born’ and ‘Sentient 6’ from the This Godless Endeavor album. Please feel free to sing as much of the song as you want. If you choose not to do the whole song, please at least sing a full verse and chorus of each song. Please also include a brief introduction about your background, influences, and what you can bring to the band. We encourage you to demonstrate everything to the best of your potential.” The ideal vocalist must be able to convey a wide range of tones and emotions, blending power and vulnerability, with expressive depth that captures the haunting themes of Nevermore‘s music. A strong stage presence is also essential, embodying the intensity of the band’s sound in a live setting.“
Bassists are invited to showcase their skills by performing “Enemies of Reality” and “Inside Four Walls.” As outlined, “Bassist: Should please play the songs ‘Enemies of Reality’ and ‘Inside Four Walls’ while standing up focusing on tightness, technique, and feel.” The band seeks a rock-solid player who can create depth and drive in their arrangements while locking in rhythmically with the drummer. Backing vocals are a bonus, but precision, groove, and a tight rhythm are paramount.“
Wondering how to submit your audition? Send Van and Jim a PRIVATE YouTube link to the following email address: [email protected]
Despite the challenges, both Van and Jeff are unwavering in their optimism: “I am personally focusing on positivity and positive people and will refuse to get tangled in the negativity of the past. If Jeff and I can find the right vocalist and bassist—musicians who respect the legacy and want to move forward with us — then this new chapter can be something truly special for all who choose to come along with us.”
1 Comment
I’m here for it. I love Nevermore. I hate how the band imploded, and all the tragedies that happened since. We have to move on from the past. I’m sure they could create a new name, and I’m pretty sure the royalties that come in will go to support the family of Warrel and Jim. At the same time, I want the music of Nevermore to be alive again. You have my blessing.